saying its impossible is a bit disingenuous.
the proper way of saying it is that its not likely for the average player, but is still technically possible.
if you buy a lottery ticket, you have a chance at winning. that doesnt mean everyone that buys the ticket wins.
in this case, its a matter of things lining up really really well. like being one of the first tier 3s, sellin mats for a bit to the whales, and then pushing to 1370 by day 1 argos.
then selling the legendary accessories, ability stones and tripod gear too whales for hilarious amounts of gold.
with that start up cash, if you invested heavily in fish you’d see a 6x profit (one time) when the fish prices went from 5g to 30g in a single day (and hovered around that for a week)
someone who did that, could make literal millions of gold. and with that gold they could fund several 1370 alts, that then feed materials too the main and slowly but surely (while also using the gold) pushing themselves to 1490.
even with this, there is still a matter of luck required.
but the fact is, it is possible.
its all about how well a person played, and truthfully the vast majority of us played poorly.
we didnt make alts quickly enough, we didnt push them too 1370 and we didnt push fast enough early on to benefit from the RMT whales.
that doesnt mean someone couldnt of done it, it just means very few people could of. you cant have hundreds of f2p 1490 players. but you could certainly have maybe 1 to 2 per server right now.
but odds are if you see someone over 1430~ rn they probably are a spender. (yes obv a 1430 could also be f2p, but again not nearly as likely as them being a spender.)