Revitalize content, add more Crystal purchases, and remove Auction House restriction to combat bots and attract new players

Attracting new players is important for keeping MMOs alive and increasing profits, even MMOs with fremium monetization strategies. Lost Ark’s new player experience does not make a good first impression though. It is prohibitively difficult to matchmake into low level content, and bots outnumber human players.

Encouraging new players to skip low level content gives the impression that much of the game is unplayable. Players may opt to play a different game with a smooth progression from the beginning to the end rather than being rushed into Lost Ark’s endgame. Challenge Abyssal Dungeons and Challenge Guardian Raids provide alternative content that new players can enjoy, but they don’t address the issues with matchmaking into existing content.

Abyssal Dungeons, Guardian Raids, Chaos Gates, and Ghost ships would all benefit from a system that matchmakes high level players under the effects of the Scales of Balance with low level players who are waiting in queue or have entered a Chaos Gate or Ghost Ship instance. This would provide a much better experience at low levels and show new players that the game is very much alive.

Goldsellers, their bots, and the inflation they cause are also very harmful to new players and give them a bad impression of the game. Actions such as having moderators visually identify bots and flag them for review or ban, removing gold from accounts that have been caught engaging in RMT, and halting suspicious purchases to prevent credit card fraud are all effective methods to impede goldsellers, but they will find ways to circumvent any method to detect them as long as it is profitable to do so. In order to stop goldsellers, you must force them out of the market.

Currently, item prices have inflated greatly while the price of Crystals has lagged behind. This makes purchasing gold with Royal Crystals prohibitively expensive. This encourages players to engage in RMT, despite the risks and the harm it does to the game. In order to make legitimate gold purchases more affordable, Crystal needs to be made more useful. There are currently few items to spend Crystal on regularly. Players hoard Pheons until they absolutely need to buy endgame gear, restricting the ingame economy and creating an environment goldsellers can exploit. The Crystalline Aura is a monthly purchase at best. Leap’s Essence is only useful until the player’s roster reaches level 30 in all Trade Skills.

Regularly adding new cosmetics, available for Crystals, would have a small but noticeable effect on the demand for Crystals and their price. Adding items that boost the drop rate or amount for Ability Stones, Accessories, Skill Books, and Honing Materials would have a much larger effect on the demand for Crystals. Gold boosters should be avoided as they would cause more inflation. Items that allow players to grind longer will not help much, because players will prefer to use an alternative character or account instead of grinding longer for reduced profit. Items that create a paywall for activities, especially trading, should be avoided as players will avoid using them as much as possible.

The goal is to encourage free players to trade item drops for gold, buy Crystals with gold, and spend Crystals to farm more item drops. Paying players will buy Royal Crystals, trade Royal Crystals for gold, and use gold to buy items that the free players are farming. As Crystal prices rise, the gold on the Currency Exchange will become more affordable and it will gradually become harder for goldsellers to compete. Free players will complain about the rising Crystal price, but as long as it is profitable to buy Crystalline Aura and drop boosters, they will continue buying and spending Crystal.

1 Like

Good luck with that.

Yeah, Pheons aren’t exactly helping the economy. AGS is reluctant to remove them too, probably because they seem to be the only thing people buy more often than Crystalline Aura. More often than once a month isn’t a very high bar though. Rather than removing them outright, AGS could add drop boosters and other such farming aids to the shop and run an event where the Auction House’s Pheon cost is temporarily disabled. If Crystal sales improve without the Pheons, then remove them completely.

How can they improve the new player experience with rampant bots + state of economy?

Honestly, the actual growth of the game has come to a halt and is just slowly bleeding out. Concurrent players number may apparently be rising according to steam charts, but realistically 99.99% are just new bot accounts inflating the number to a sever misleading degree. Then it could be argued, that new player retention is so bad that they will shortly quit the game whether it’s from seeing all the bots, honing, economy, etc as there have been various posts on the forums recently describing an actual new player pov to why they quit the game as well.

TLDR: AGS will never be able to improve the new player experience nor make significant improvements on the existing player experience as long as bots run rampant. They’re literally the core issue that branches off into a multitude of other issues and inconveniences that have taken place over the past 10 months. AGS/SG has shown their lack of urgency, poor leadership + management and high incompetence so honestly don’t expect them to make any positive progress in redirecting this game in a better direction

1 Like

Yep that is one of the points I pointed out in the player feedback questionnaire. It’s important to attract and keep new players and also encourage teamplay

They can’t. That’s why I suggested ways to fix the economy and push goldsellers and their bots out of the market. If they can get free players to buy more Crystals with gold, they can make it harder for goldsellers to compete.

Not sure about economy in total. But the price of crystals has decreased greatly the last weeks (down to 1,9k on EUC) because of the engraving vendor.

They wont go much lower either. Considering if you have 6 chars running legion raids, you make 70k-80k gold per week without selling any mats.

That won’t work in Lost Ark, since the game allows pretty much anybody to print large sum of gold in weekly basis out of legion raids. With gold being that easy to come by, there would be no reason to make people spend on the game. That’s why pheons exist and it’s not going to change.

Making even more content ‘scaled’ or ‘equalized’ wouldn’t do any good either. I see no reason to be bothered with it even now while I can oneshot it with less than 2 minutes.

If everybody had enough gold, nobody would be buying it from goldsellers. Besides, people will always look for a way to squeeze a little more efficiency out of their grind, even if they have enough gold. Players spend as few Pheons as possible by avoiding buying anything but their meta accessories and stones. Honestly, I don’t think the money AGS makes from Pheons is worth the business they lose to goldsellers.

They’d lose the money anyway. Removing pheons is not going to decrease bot accounts.
SG designed the game thinking nobody but them can provide extra gold & stuff to the players.
Now they have competition, that outsmarted them by a large margin.

Not directly.

Yes. Now AGS needs to drive the competition out of business.

To do that, you have to make it cheaper to buy gold with Royal Crystal. To do that, you have to increase the demand for Crystal. To do that, you have to give free players more things to buy with Crystal, and if you put something in the store that will let them make more gold or make gold faster, they will buy it up and use it whenever possible.

Pheons make it more difficult to sell accessories and stones though. They are an obstacle.

Makes sense if you think about it.

I changed the title to better reflect my suggestions. It is a mouthful though. :sweat_smile: